Council says no to Mayor’s pick for Chief

Interim Police Chief Bill Peterson’s connection to MPD seen as an asset and drawback

  • Council says no to Mayor’s pick for Chief_Cam Gordon.mp3

Posted

The Minneapolis City Council voted to reject Mayor Jacob Frey’s nomination of Minneapolis Police Department’s Interim Police Chief Bill Peterson to be the city’s next police chief on Nov. 12.

The City Council voted 8-5, the majority against nominating Peterson. His nomination followed the unexpected resignation of Chief Brian O‘Hara, and a national search process.

The long, and sometimes emotional, hearing included tearful testimony from Tori Myslajek, the fiance of MPD officer Jamal Mitchell. Mitchell was killed in the line of duty in 2024. Myslajek testified with two of their young children at her side.

Supporting Frey’s nomination were three of Southwest’s council members: Ward 7 Council Member Elizabeth Shaffer, Ward 11’s Jamison Whiting and Ward 13’s Linea Palmisano. They joined Ward 3’s Michael Rainville and Ward 6’s Jamal Osman to support Peterson’s appointment.

Two Southwest council members, Ward 8’s Soren Stevenson and Ward 10’s Aisha Chughtai, joined Council President Elliott Payne, and council members Robin Wonsley, LaTrisha Vetaw, Pearl Warren, Jason Chavez and Aurin Chowdhury in voting to deny the nomination.

Peterson joined the MPD in 1995 and most recently led the downtown and Cedar Riverside’s 1st Police Precinct before taking on his current role as interim police chief earlier this year.

His experience working for MPD was seen as both a strength and a weakness to council members.

SUPPORT FOR PETERSON
“You have shown us who you are in your 30 years with MPD,” said Palmisano to Peterson, at the Nov. 12 council meeting before the vote. “You are in the unique position of having experienced the culture of MPD and understanding the need for change.”

Palmisano’s comments echoed Frey’s nomination letter.

“Bill Peterson is the right leader for this moment,” wrote Frey. “He’s spent three decades serving Minneapolis, earned the respect of officers across the department, and understands that trust with the people of Minneapolis is paramount.”

Ward 7 resident Phyllis Roden voiced her support of Peterson at a public hearing on Nov. 4.

“To confirm one of its own, a man who has built a career of impeccable integrity at MPD and who has earned the respect of the MPD family,” Roden said, “To lead that family through the challenges that it faces is, in the opinion of this Minneapolitan, a slam dunk for the City of Minneapolis. Interim Police Chief Bill Peterson should be confirmed in the role of Chief without hesitation and without delay.”

Well before Frey made the nomination in September, five council members wrote a letter making the case for a new chief without a history within the MPD, saying they would not support an internal candidate.

“There is a unique dysfunction and mismanagement of the City’s police department that is not found elsewhere,” wrote Chughtai, Stevenson, Payne, Wonsley and Chavez in a joint letter. “Despite promises of change, police officers who have already harmed and broken the public’s trust continue to cycle in and out of important roles…The challenges our city faces at this moment make it clear that we need an individual whose professional experience is not primarily within the Minneapolis Police Department.”

Diane Moe from Ward 8, a former member of a City police oversight committee, was one of the 45 people who spoke at the Nov. 4 public hearing.

“Chief Peterson is well known and respected throughout the department. The many officers I have spoken with say morale is at an all-time high,” Moe said. “He has made some difficult decisions with compassion and honesty. I firmly believe Interim Chief Peterson will reform the department, ensure better compliance with state civil rights mandates, and address ongoing issues with fiscal management and budget overruns.”

Shaffer wrote at length about her support for Peterson after the hearing.

“We heard from about 50 speakers from a wide range of backgrounds, and they spoke overwhelmingly in support of (Interim Chief) Peterson,” Shaffer wrote. “Several themes ran through their testimony: his integrity, his responsiveness, and his ability to bring people together.”

Groups and individuals who formally supported Peterson’s appointment include: All of Mpls (an independent expenditure political action committee), the Pohland Companies, the Minnesota Sports Facilities Authority chair, the directors of Public Safety from Blaine, Plymouth, Richfield, Bloomington, and Minneapolis Park and Recreation Board, the commissioner of the State of Minnesota’s Department of Public Safety, MAD DADS Minneapolis, Hennepin County Sheriff Dawanna Witt, the superintendent of Minnesota’s Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, the Downtown Council, the Downtown Improvement District, the director of Twin Cities Pride and the CEO of Youthlink.

CRITICISM OF PETERSON
Criticism for Peterson was heard both on and off the council.

Two local police accountability groups, Communities United Against Police Brutality and Twin Cities Coalition for Justice, testified in their opposition to Peterson’s appointment.

“The most important job of any leader is to shape the culture of the organization they lead,” said Ward 7 resident and President of CUAPB Michelle Gross. “Bill Peterson is steeped in the same old culture that led to the murder of George Floyd. His history of complaints and misconduct make it clear that he is not the leader we need.”

According to Gross and records shared on CUAPB’s website, Peterson has a history of formal complaints with two still outstanding. Peterson was also part of at least one lawsuit.

He was one of several defendants in a lawsuit that resulted in a settlement agreement with the city that arose from the execution of a search warrant in 2007 when the Metro Gang Strike Force, Peterson and the other defendants were accused of applying the warrant without probable cause, using excessive force, exceeding the lawful scope of the search, damaging property and illegally detaining people in violation of their rights.

During the November council meetings, council members said they did not feel Peterson was as aware and sensitive to concerns about racism and discrimination on the force as they would have liked.

Wonsley asked Peterson if he had heard racial slurs or discriminatory language about race, gender, or sexual orientation within MPD. Peterson said he didn’t recall hearing any.

“Peterson’s claim that he has never heard slurs against racial or gendered groups in over 30 years within the Minneapolis Police Department is a huge red flag,” Wonsley wrote in an email after the hearing. “I am very concerned about Peterson’s willingness to challenge the ’Thin Blue Line’ mentality of officers protecting each other from accountability.”

Vetaw said that her opposition to the appointment was based on her preference for another internal candidate, MPD Deputy Chief of Investigations Charlie Adams.

WHAT IS NEXT FOR APPOINTING A CHIEF
The mayor can veto the council’s vote against Peterson’s appointment. Without a veto, if the mayor allows the council vote to stand, a new search process or nomination could be started at any time by the mayor.

At the Council meeting, before the vote was taken, Peterson said that if he is not appointed, he is happy to remain as interim chief as long as he is needed in that capacity. He said he has no plans to leave the department.
The City Charter does not have a time limit specifying a maximum number of days or months an interim police chief can remain in office. So, Peterson could potentially remain in place for the remainder of the term or even longer.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here